Private clubs have built their reputation on prestige, exceptional hospitality, and an environment where members expect a high level of service, privacy, trust, and security.

Maintaining that reputation requires more than beautiful facilities and outstanding amenities. It begins with creating a strong culture and hiring the right people to support it.

The question club leadership should ask is simple:

Have we taken reasonable steps to know who we are allowing into our members’ environment?

Recent data from a club association survey found that 75% of clubs experienced incidents over the past two years that could potentially lead to insurance claims or legal exposure, while 50% indicated they want to actively improve their safety and compliance culture.

These findings highlight an important reality: the people a club hires can have a significant impact on the safety of its members, employees and guests, and ultimately, the club’s reputation and brand.

A serious incident involving an employee can extend far beyond the individual event. It can affect member trust and safety, employee morale, insurance costs, legal exposure, and the reputation a club may have spent decades building.

That is why employee background screening should not be viewed simply as an HR requirement to “check the box.” It should be viewed as an important component of a club’s overall risk-management strategy.

A sobering fact is that lawsuit settlements in “negligent hiring” and other screening cases, involving serious assault, sexual misconduct or violence have been reported in amounts ranging from approximately $250,000 to more than $2 million. Proper background screening of your employees reduces this risk dramatically.

5 Best Practices for Effective Employee Screening

1. Conduct Comprehensive Background Screening

There is no single, centralized database containing every criminal record in the United States. Criminal records are maintained at different levels of government and across thousands of jurisdictions.

That makes it important for clubs to work with a qualified background screening provider to develop a screening package appropriate for their workforce and level of risk.

A comprehensive screening program may include county-level criminal searches, state-level searches, federal criminal searches and national database (e.g., sex offender) searches, followed by appropriate searches at the source level when potential records are identified.

Clubs should also consider whether additional searches are appropriate for particular positions, including:

Candidates may have lived in multiple jurisdictions or used different names or aliases. A properly designed background screening program can help identify information that might otherwise be missed by relying on a single database or a single jurisdiction. For private clubs, the objective is to develop a more complete and accurate picture of the individual being considered for employment.

2. Address the New Challenge of AI, Deepfakes and Identity Fraud

Hiring has entered a new era.

Artificial intelligence (AI) can help legitimate candidates improve resumes and prepare for interviews. However, that same technology is also being used to fabricate credentials, create false identities and deceive employers during the hiring process.

A new study predicts that by 2028, 1 in 4 candidate profiles worldwide will be completely fake, with 73% of onboarding professionals already reporting challenges with fabricated or misleading candidate information. Now, traditional hiring practices need additional safeguards.

Clubs should consider combining in-person interviews, identity verification, employment and other screening tools to help confirm that the person applying for the position is actually the real person being hired.

Hiring teams should also pay attention to inconsistencies throughout the process. Contradictory information, unexplained gaps, unusual changes to a candidate’s story, or discrepancies between application materials and independently verified information may warrant additional review.

Technology can be part of the solution, but it should complement and not replace sound human judgment and established hiring procedures.

3. Verify Employment and Education at the Primary Source

One of the most important elements of a background check is verifying that a candidate’s resume accurately reflects their experience and qualifications.

Resume inflation can range from relatively minor exaggerations to significant misrepresentations of employment history, job responsibilities, education or professional credentials.

Conservative surveys have shown that 38% of employment verifications and 27% of education verifications demonstrated a “discrepancy” or “fabrication” to HR representatives. The message for employers is clear:

What a candidate says on a resume should not automatically be treated as verified information.

Primary source verification helps address this issue by going directly to the appropriate employer, educational institution, licensing authority or other authoritative source to verify the information provided.

For a private club, this can be particularly important when hiring individuals for positions involving significant responsibility, access to members, financial information, facilities, residences, vehicles or other sensitive areas.

Trust, but verify.

4. Get the Forms and Documentation Right

Background screening is not simply about searching databases. The entire process matters!

When a club obtains a consumer report for employment purposes, there are important federal and state requirements governing disclosures, authorization, notices, adverse-action procedures and the handling of consumer information.

Requirements can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the type of screening being conducted. Some states and local jurisdictions also have additional requirements governing when and how criminal history information may be considered.

Working with a reliable background screening firm can help clubs establish appropriate processes and provide the required documentation to candidates.

Proper documentation helps demonstrate that the club has established a consistent, compliant screening process rather than making decisions on an ad hoc basis.

For club leadership and boards, this is an important distinction:

A compliant and comprehensive background screening program creates a defensible process.

5. Address the Common Myths About Employee Screening

When implementing or expanding a screening program, club leadership or boards may have questions about cost, turnaround time or whether screening can simply be handled internally.

Here are three common misconceptions:

MYTH: Background checks take too long.
FACT: Most routine employment background checks can be completed within two to three business days.

MYTH: Background screening is too expensive.
FACT: At approximately $50-$75 per candidate, a comprehensive employee background check is a small investment compared with the potentially hundreds of thousands, or even millions, of dollars in legal costs, settlements, and damages that can result from a negligent hiring claim.

Once hired, the cost of training and onboarding a new employee can quickly reach thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars. Conducting a thorough background and social media screening before making the hiring decision will help identify potential concerns early, allowing you to invest the right time and resources in candidates who are the right fit from the start.

MYTH: We can conduct the searches ourselves.
FACT: While clubs can conduct certain searches internally, professional background screening providers have access to specialized search processes and can help identify potential records across jurisdictions, verify information, conduct appropriate searches and apply applicable reporting requirements.

A qualified screening provider also understands that finding information and legally reporting information are not necessarily the same thing.

Protecting the Brand Starts with the People You Hire

A private club’s brand builds its reputation over years but can be damaged in a matter of days by one bad hire!

A comprehensive, consistently administered employee screening program can help clubs make more informed hiring decisions, strengthen their risk-management practices and protect the trust that members place in their organization.

The right hire can strengthen your club’s culture and reputation. The wrong hire can put both at risk.

For private clubs, background screening is about protecting your members, your employees, your reputation and the quality brand you and others have worked so hard to build.

Members join private clubs for a variety of reasons, but one thing that they expect without doubt is that it is a safe place. A “best-practices” background check can help prevent a discoverable threat from gaining access to your club, members and team.

Posted by: Rudy Troisi, L.P.I., Founder, CEO, and Dr. Alan Lasky, SVP Business Development and Partnerships.

This content is for informational purposes only and not legal advice or binding case law. Consult qualified legal counsel for assistance.

Copyright © 2026, Reliable Background Screening, a Division of Marcett, Inc. All rights reserved.